Why a cat cannot eat like a dog
Cats are obligate carnivores: taurine, vitamin A and other nutrients they must get ready made from the diet explain why dog food is not right for them.
- Audience
- Pet owners
- Species
- Cat, Dog
- Scope
- Valid everywhere
It looks like a harmless convenience: the dog's tin is open, the cat steals a mouthful, and after all it is all pet food. In reality dogs and cats have different evolutionary histories and metabolisms, and feeding a cat with dog food on a continuous basis can lead to serious deficiencies. The dog is an omnivore with strong carnivorous tendencies, able to draw energy and nutrients from a more varied diet. The cat is an obligate carnivore, an animal whose body has specialised to the point of depending on meat to obtain substances that the dog, instead, can build for itself from simpler ingredients. It is not a matter of taste or habit: it is a biological difference that translates into specific requirements. Understanding which nutrients these are and why the cat cannot do without them helps you choose the right food and avoid mistakes that seem small but add up over time.
Obligate carnivore is not just a phrase
Calling the cat an obligate carnivore is not an evocative label but a precise description of its metabolism. Over evolution, feeding almost exclusively on animal prey, the cat lost or reduced some metabolic pathways that stay active in omnivores, because it found those nutrients ready made in meat and had no need to produce them. This specialisation made it an efficient hunter, but dependent on a diet of animal origin to stay well.
The dog took a different road. Adapting to life with people and a more varied diet, it kept the ability to use a wider range of ingredients and to synthesise some substances itself. That is why a food formulated for dogs does not cover a cat's needs: it is not wrong for the dog, it is simply built on a different metabolism. Giving a cat dog food occasionally is a minor incident, but making it their regular diet exposes them to deficiencies.
The nutrients the cat must get ready made
The heart of the difference lies in some nutrients the cat cannot produce in sufficient amounts and must therefore take from the diet, already formed. These are the substances that make dog food unsuitable as a cat's regular diet. The table gathers the main ones with the reason they matter.
| Nutrient | Why the cat depends on it | If missing for long |
|---|---|---|
| Taurine | The cat makes too little and finds it in animal tissue | Heart problems and damage to vision |
| Preformed vitamin A | It does not efficiently convert plant precursors | Skin, eye and general disorders |
| Arachidonic acid | It does not synthesise it from other plant fats | Changes in skin, clotting and reproduction |
| A high protein share | It uses part of it for energy almost continuously | Loss of muscle mass and weakness |
| Some amino acids such as arginine | Needed for the cycle that clears nitrogen waste | Risk of toxic build up even after a single deficient meal |
Taurine is the best known example. Its deficiency was linked in the past to a serious heart disease and to vision problems in cats, and precisely for this reason good complete cat foods now contain it in adequate amounts. Dog food is not formulated to guarantee these levels, and this is one of the reasons it cannot replace a food designed for the cat.
Why the cat needs more protein and water in its food
Beyond individual nutrients, the overall setup of the diet changes. The cat uses protein as an energy source almost constantly, even when it has other sources available, and for this reason it needs a higher protein content than the dog. A diet too low in protein, perhaps suitable for a dog, means for a cat drawing on its own muscle reserves.
- A higher protein requirement: the cat burns protein for energy almost continuously and does not spare it the way an omnivore does.
- A limited ability to handle very carbohydrate rich diets compared with the dog, with which excess should be avoided.
- A weak thirst response: the cat tends to drink little and draws much of its water from food, as it would from prey.
- A preference for small, frequent meals, reflecting the natural pattern of hunting several times a day.
- Sensitivity to taste and texture, which makes the cat more selective and attached to feeding habits.
Choosing and managing the cat's food in practice
Turning these principles into daily choices is simpler than it seems, because a good complete cat food is already formulated to cover its needs. The carer's task is to choose it with judgement and manage cohabitation with any dogs in the home.
Choose a complete food designed for cats
Check on the label that it is declared complete for the feline species and for the right life stage. A complete food is formulated to provide all essential nutrients, taurine included.
Do not use dog food as the cat's regular meal
An occasional stolen mouthful is not a disaster, but dog food must not become the cat's diet, because it does not guarantee the nutrients the cat needs.
Separate the bowls in a dog and cat home
Distinct stations, often raised for the cat, prevent each from eating the other's food. This way the cat gets its food and the dog gets his.
Match the food to life stage and condition
Kitten, adult, senior and animals with conditions have different needs. Diets for specific conditions should be set up with the vet, not improvised.
Be wary of unformulated homemade diets
A homemade cat diet is easy to unbalance precisely on the critical nutrients. If you want to follow one, have it formulated by a nutrition professional, not by copying generic recipes.
Always ensure fresh water and consider wet food
Clean water always available and a share of wet food help hydrate an animal that naturally drinks little.
A particularly risky mistake: plant based diets
Precisely because the cat is an obligate carnivore, diets without animal ingredients are far more problematic for it than for the dog. Removing the natural source of taurine, preformed vitamin A and arachidonic acid means having to replace these nutrients precisely with supplements, an operation that is hard to do correctly and to maintain over time without risk.
For this reason a vegetarian or vegan diet for a cat is not a choice to make on your own based on personal beliefs. If you want to explore this path, it should be done only with the guidance of a vet experienced in nutrition, with foods formulated and supplemented in a verified way and with regular checks. Improvising means exposing the cat to exactly the deficiencies this article describes, and the resulting damage can be serious and not always reversible.
Frequently asked questions
- My cat occasionally steals the dog's food: is it dangerous?
- An occasional mouthful does not cause deficiencies and is no cause for alarm. The problem arises when dog food becomes a steady or main part of the cat's diet, because it is not formulated to provide the nutrients the cat needs, such as taurine in adequate amounts. If it happens often at home, it is worth separating the bowls so each eats its own food.
- Can I give my dog the cat's food if his has run out?
- Occasionally the dog tolerates cat food better than the cat tolerates dog food, because cat food is richer in certain nutrients. It is still not suitable as a dog's regular diet, because the profile is calibrated for another metabolism and over time proves unbalanced and too rich in some components. As an occasional solution it is fine, as a diet it is not.
- Should taurine be added with a supplement?
- Not if the cat eats a good complete food designed for its species, because these foods are already formulated to contain it in adequate amounts. Supplementation makes sense only in particular situations and on the vet's advice, for example in some formulated homemade diets or specific clinical conditions. Adding supplements at random is not helpful and can unbalance the diet.
- Is a vegetarian diet fine for a cat?
- The cat is an obligate carnivore and depends on nutrients of animal origin such as taurine, preformed vitamin A and arachidonic acid. A diet without animal ingredients requires a precise, verified replacement of these substances, hard to manage alone. If you want to take this path, do it only with a veterinary nutritionist and regular checks, never improvising, because deficiencies in cats can be serious.
What to do next
Remember that the cat is an obligate carnivore and depends on animal nutrients the dog can build for itself, such as taurine, preformed vitamin A and arachidonic acid. Choose for it a complete food formulated for the feline species and its life stage, do not use dog food as a regular meal, separate the bowls at home and ensure water and a share of wet food. For homemade or plant based diets always rely on a veterinary nutritionist.
Related content
- Read10 min read
How to actually read the label on a complete pet food
You cannot compare two foods by reading the percentages on the front of the bag. You need dry matter, the ingredient list and energy density, in that order.
DogCat - Read10 min read
Feeding the cat with kidney disease or diabetes: what really changes
In the two most common chronic diseases of cats, diet does not support treatment: to a large extent it is the treatment. And a cat that refuses the food defeats the best plan.
Cat - Read8 min read
The fussy cat: food neophobia and how to handle it
A cat that circles the bowl and walks off is not being difficult: it is often neophobia, distrust of new food. Here is how to read it and how to widen its menu.
Cat